Skip to content

Federal Court: Unvaccinated Children Don’t Have Full Rights to Public Education

Parents’ constitutional right to freely exercise their religion does not necessarily except their children from receiving vaccinations, provided the parents want their children to attend classes at publicly funded schools.
Sign up for Big Think on Substack
The most surprising and impactful new stories delivered to your inbox every week, for free.

What’s the Latest?

Parents’ constitutional right to freely exercise their religion does not necessarily except their children from receiving vaccinations, provided the parents want their children to attend classes at publicly funded schools. This is the ruling handed down last week by the Brooklyn Federal District Court which cited a 1905 Supreme Court ruling permitting the state of Massachusetts to fine individuals refusing to receive the smallpox vaccine. “[Brooklyn District Court] Judge William Kuntz ruled that the court had ‘strongly suggested that religious objectors are not constitutionally exempt from vaccinations.'”

What’s the Big Idea?

Given that 48 states, including New York, currently allow for individuals to object to receiving vaccinations on religious grounds, the Brooklyn ruling is likely to be revisited by a higher court in the near future. From a public policy standpoint, the ruling seems to make good sense: “Earlier this spring, during a measles outbreak in New York, the unvaccinated sibling of a home-schooled child who’d been infected was barred from attending public school. That sibling ultimately contracted the disease, and keeping him home prevented it from spreading further.”

Read more at Vox

Photo credit: Shutterstock

Sign up for Big Think on Substack
The most surprising and impactful new stories delivered to your inbox every week, for free.
Related
A bearded man wearing glasses and a plaid shirt speaks with a microphone clipped to his collar in front of a purple background with white dots.
The Well
How Rainn Wilson discovered sacredness
The hospital where Rainn Wilson’s wife and son nearly died became his own personal holy site. There, he discovered that the sacred can exist in places we least expect it. During his talk at A Night of Awe and Wonder, he explained how the awe we feel in moments of courage and love is moral beauty — and following it might be the start of our spiritual revolution.
▸
13 min
—
with
Rainn Wilson
Up Next